Exploring the Use of Credit Checks During the Hiring Process

Last Updated:
March 16, 2023

When it comes to hiring new employees, many employers are now turning to credit checks as part of the process. Credit checks can provide employers with valuable insight into a potential candidate’s background and financial histeory.

However, the use of credit checks during the hiring process has become increasingly controversial in recent years due to its potential for discrimination. At Fair Credit, we believe that credit checks can be used responsibly and ethically during the hiring process. 

We specialize in helping our clients fight errors on their credit reports, background checks, and tenant screenings, so they can confidently present themselves to potential employers. 

In this article, we’ll explore the use of credit checks during the hiring process, discuss potential risks involved, and provide guidance on how to ensure that credit checks are used responsibly. 

Let’s get started.

Why to Consider Using Credit Checks in Hiring

Credit checks have become a common component in the hiring process. Employers use credit checks to assess the financial responsibility of potential employees and identify any potential risks they may pose to the organization. Some of the key reasons to use credit checks in the hiring process include:

Assess Financial Responsibility

Credit checks are a simple and effective way to assess a candidate’s financial responsibility. Although not a perfectly accurate measure and, a good credit score does tend to indicate that a candidate is responsible with their finances and pays their bills on time. This can be an important consideration for plenty of employers, particularly those in industries where employees handle money, such as finance or accounting.

Identify Potential Employee Risks

Credit checks can also help employers identify potential risks associated with hiring a particular candidate. For example, if a candidate has a history of defaulting on loans or a significant amount of debt, it may indicate that they are at risk of financial distress. This can be a concern for employers, particularly if the role involves access to sensitive financial information.

Prevent Employee Theft and Fraud

Credit checks can also help prevent employee theft and fraud. In some cases, employees who are in financial distress may be more likely to engage in fraudulent activity or theft. By screening candidates for financial responsibility, employers can reduce the risk of such incidents occurring in the workplace.

Compliance with Industry Regulations

Certain industries, such as banking and finance, are subject to regulatory requirements that mandate the use of credit checks in the hiring process. In these cases, credit checks are necessary to ensure compliance with industry regulations and protect the organization from legal liability.

By understanding the potential benefits of credit checks, employers can ensure that they are being used responsibly and ethically during their hiring process. 

Concerns about Using Credit Checks in Hiring

While credit checks can be useful in assessing a candidate’s financial responsibility and identifying potential risks, many employers have valid concerns about using credit checks in the hiring process. For example:

Possible Discrimination

Credit checks may lead to discriminatory hiring practices, as employers may be more likely to reject candidates who have poor credit histories. This can be particularly problematic for those from disadvantaged backgrounds or with limited access to resources, as they are more likely to have poorer credit scores.

Inaccurate Representation of Financial Responsibility

Credit checks may not always accurately represent a candidate’s financial responsibility. A candidate may have a low credit score due to factors outside of their control, such as medical debt or identity theft. Similarly, a candidate may have a good credit score despite being financially irresponsible.

Inability to Consider Personal Circumstances

Credit checks may not take into account personal circumstances that may affect a candidate’s financial situation. For example, a candidate may have incurred significant debt due to a family emergency or job loss. In such cases, a credit check may not accurately reflect a candidate’s financial responsibility.

Disproportionate Impact on Certain Populations

Credit checks may have a disproportionate impact on certain populations, such as minorities or those with low income. This can perpetuate systemic inequality and discrimination in the hiring process, which is a concern for employers who are committed to creating a diverse and inclusive workplace.

Thankfully, applicants who believe their credit report has errors can contact Fair Credit to dispute any inaccuracies. If you’re facing this issue, our team is here to help.

Legal Considerations

Companies that conduct credit checks on applicants must observe the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), state laws, and Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) regulations to stay compliant.

Fair Credit Reporting Act

The FCRA is a federal law that regulates the collection, use, and distribution of consumer credit information. Employers who use credit checks in the hiring process must comply with the FCRA’s requirements.

This includes providing notice and obtaining written consent from the candidate before conducting a credit check, using a reputable credit reporting agency, and providing the candidate with a copy of the credit report and a summary of their rights under the FCRA.

State Laws Regarding Credit Checks

In addition to federal requirements, employers must also comply with state laws regarding credit checks. Some states have implemented laws that restrict or prohibit the use of credit checks in hiring, particularly for certain roles or industries. Employers must be aware of state-specific requirements and ensure that their hiring practices comply with applicable laws.

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission Guidelines

The EEOC has issued guidelines that prohibit the use of credit checks in hiring if it has a disproportionate impact on certain populations, particularly those protected by anti-discrimination laws. 

Employers have a responsibility to make sure that their recruiting processes remain unbiased towards potential candidates, regardless of race, gender, age, or other personal characteristics.

Ultimately, credit checks can be a useful tool for employers when used responsibly and within legal requirements. However, employers should carefully consider the potential consequences of using credit checks in their hiring process and ensure that their practices comply with all applicable laws.

Alternatives to Credit Checks

While credit checks can be a useful tool in assessing a candidate’s financial responsibility and identifying potential risks, there are also alternative methods that employers can use to make hiring decisions. Some of the key alternatives to credit checks include:

Skills and Experience Assessments

Employers can assess a candidate’s skills and experience through a variety of assessments, such as job simulations, written tests, or practical exercises. These assessments can provide insights into a candidate’s abilities and potential fit for the role without relying on credit information.

Behavioral Assessments

Behavioral assessments are another alternative to credit checks that can provide insights into a candidate’s character and work style. These assessments typically involve a series of questions or scenarios that evaluate a candidate’s personality traits, work habits, and communication skills.

Interviews and References

Interviews and references are a traditional and reliable method for evaluating a candidate’s suitability for a role. Interviews can provide insights into a candidate’s skills, experience, and personality, while references can provide feedback on a candidate’s work history and character.

While credit checks have their place in the hiring process, employers should also consider utilizing alternative methods to evaluate candidates. These alternatives can help employers make more informed decisions about which candidate is best suited for the role without relying solely on credit information.

Tips to Comply with Laws When Using Credit Checks

Employers who use credit checks in the hiring process must follow best practices to ensure compliance with legal requirements and reduce the risk of discrimination. Some of the key best practices for credit checks include:

Using Credit Checks Appropriately

Employers should only use credit checks when they are necessary and relevant to the role. For example, credit checks may be appropriate for roles that involve handling sensitive financial information or managing finances. Employers should avoid using credit checks for roles that do not require access to financial information or have no bearing on the candidate’s financial responsibility.

Ensuring Compliance with FCRA

Companies must comply with all of the FCRA’s conditions when performing credit checks, such as giving notification and getting written approval from applicants, utilizing a reliable credit reporting institution, plus furnishing them with an outline of their rights under the Fair Credit Reporting Act together with a copy of their report.

Mitigating Potential for Discrimination

Employers should be aware of the potential for discrimination in the use of credit checks and take steps to mitigate this risk. This may involve using credit checks only after making a conditional job offer, allowing candidates to explain any negative credit history, and considering alternative methods of assessing a candidate’s suitability for the role.

Providing Notification and Obtaining Consent

Employers must provide notification and obtain written consent from candidates before conducting a credit check. This should include a clear explanation of the purpose and scope of the credit check, the identity of the credit reporting agency, and the candidate’s rights under the FCRA.

Contact Fair Credit for Assistance

Credit checks are quickly becoming a popular tool used by employers to gain better insight into their potential hires and make sound, informed decisions.

Unfortunately, errors on credit reports are all too common, and they can have a negative impact on a candidate’s employment prospects. If you believe there is an error on your credit report, get in touch with Fair Credit for assistance. Our experts specialize in helping clients to fight unfair credit report errors and get the best results possible. Contact us today for more information.

Ready to take action?

Don't let these companies get away with violating your rights and causing you financial & emotional distress.

Free Case Review